I attended the West End’s wildest Christmas show – a woman nearly dropped on my face

When you get dressed for a West End show, you rarely consider the possibility of becoming part of it.

Sure, you want to look vaguely put-together, but if you see as much theatre as I do, your main concern is usually selecting trousers with a waistband that won’t slowly cut off circulation during two hours of sitting elbow-to-elbow with strangers.

You probably reach for those unflattering-but-essential glasses so you can actually see what’s happening on stage. And maybe, if you’re feeling exceptionally organised, you even consider whether you’ll be warm enough by the time you have to walk to the tube after the curtain falls.

What you don’t think about — and what I now beg you to factor in — is how your outfit will look when you suddenly find yourself lying on your back in front of a cheering crowd while a woman is catapulted over your head.

Because if you head to Sophie’s Surprise Party at Underbelly Soho, that might just be your evening.

The show bills itself: ‘Featuring world-class performers from Cirque du Soleil, La Clique and The 7 Fingers and fresh from its sell-out run at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, this isn’t just a house party – it’s award-winning circus at its very finest.’

The simple premise is that it’s Sophie’s birthday, and a ragtag group of characters has assembled to celebrate. The twist? Each night, Sophie is a different audience member.

And on the night I attended — fresh from work in my partner’s oversized sweater, frumpy-but-warm wool trousers, not a stitch of makeup, and blue-light glasses that scream ‘I have a desk job and am approaching 30’ — I was Sophie.

There I was, plonked on stage in a birthday hat and thrust into the centre of a rowdy opening number as if I’d been rehearsing with the cast for weeks, the audience howling at my attempts to keep up.

Within minutes, I’d been lifted, spun, danced around, and positioned on my back like a human crash mat while performers sailed above me with only inches to spare.

At first, it felt like my recurring nightmare in which I’m shoved into my high school’s production of The Crucible, know none of the lines, and am — for no clear reason — completely naked.

But then it swerved toward a Phantom of the Opera–style fantasy, the kind where you’re yanked onstage after the ingénue breaks a leg in a tragic fall (‘You’re the only one who can fit her costume! You have to! The critics are here! The show must go on!’), you deliver a miraculous performance, and are instantly anointed the West End’s freshest overnight sensation.

Where it actually landed was somewhere delightfully in between: that childlike, giddy joy of letting yourself be vulnerable, rolling with the punches, and laughing at yourself along with a room full of strangers, even if you felt your cheeks reddening.

So many of us take ourselves so relentlessly seriously, and in the age of Instagram, being seen in a way you don’t control can feel like a personal crisis.

But in that room, it felt like a liberating reminder that sometimes the best nights are the ones where you stop curating and start participating.

And of course, part of the magic is Underbelly Soho itself.

With its speakeasy-meets-circus vibe and a layout that forces audiences past two bars before they even sit down, it’s possibly the only West End venue where accidentally having two bottles of wine at your pre-show dinner is the right energy.

And don’t assume that if you aren’t crowned Sophie for the night, you’re safe.

Later, a performer suspended by her hair climbed an enthusiastic audience member like a tree before briefly straddling his face, then spun above the crowd as he gaped up at her in awe.

Another audience member helped a nude clown mid-ping-pong-ball routine into a pair of shorts as the audience howled.

Despite the mild nudity, Sophie’s Surprise never drifts into territory that would make you avert your eyes from your parents — depending on your parents, of course. In many ways, it’s a great family activity, the perfect mischievous antidote to the seasonal onslaught of carols, eggnog, and earnest holiday fare.

Still, it’s not a children’s pantomime either. After a will-they-won’t-they romance between three performers, I was asked to choose between them — a decision that involved my impulsively requesting one take his shirt off.

I earned a sweat-soaked tank top to the face for my efforts, clearly a spontaneous decision on the part of the performer that made it clear this show is really a living, breathing, changing thing.

And yes — at one point I was asked, in front of a packed theatre, what my favourite form of contraception is.

What sets Sophie’s Surprise apart is the pure, unfiltered liveness of it all. Even the best theatre on the West End can lull you into a dreamy detachment, so polished and well-lit that it’s easy to forget it wasn’t pre-recorded weeks ago.

But this show? You’re in it, even if you aren’t Sophie. You might get sweat on, be grabbed from your seat, or a ping-pong ball may whiz past your ear.

It’s impossible to forget that what you’re watching, and occasionally participating in, is real, unpredictable, shared human performance.

The death-defying stunts feel genuinely death-defying, and the comedy leaves space for enough improv to keep it fresh and new every night.

Not once did I spot an audience member with that far-off look that says they’ve zoned out and started thinking about KPIs or P&Ls. No one checked their texts during a lull, because there were no lulls.

And in the age of tiny attention spans and glowing phone screens, that much presence in one room feels like something of a miracle.

Is my jumper a little sweatier than I’d normally expect from a night at the theatre? Absolutely. But if a dry cleaning bill is the price of remembering why live performance thrills me in the first place, it’s a bargain.

Sophie’s Surprise Party runs from November 21 2025 to January 10 2026. Buy tickets here.

Got a story?

If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.

Comments


Add as preferred source