One of “The Gilded Age”âs biggest strengths is how it blends historical fact with juicy fictional drama. HBOâs 1880s New York society saga doesnât just craft intrigue out of thin air â it often pulls from real-life scandals, rivalries, and high-society figures.
Among the showâs most colorful personalities is Ward McAllister, played by Nathan Lane. Onscreen, heâs Mrs. Lina Astorâs (Donna Murphy) trusted gatekeeper to the cityâs elite. But in season 3, McAllisterâs thirst for attention â and penchant for gossip â backfires spectacularly. And just like in the series, the real Ward McAllisterâs social downfall was rooted in a scandalous book that rattled the wealthy.
What Happens to Ward McAllister in ‘The Gilded Age’
In season 3, episode 7, âEx-Communicated,â McAllister publishes his memoirs, Society as I Have Found It, hoping to cement his legacy. Instead, the tell-all becomes his undoing. While he avoids naming names, the thinly veiled references are obvious to everyone in New York high society â and they are furious.
Mrs. Fish (Ashlie Atkinson) fumes when McAllister mocks her husbandâs taste in wine. Agnes van Rhijn (Christine Baranski) is aghast at references to her lost fortune and subtle allusions to Oscarâs (Blake Ritson) sexuality. Bertha Russell (Carrie Coon) scrambles to quash rumors that her marriage to George (Morgan Spector) is in trouble. But the most furious of all is Mrs. Astor, who wants to stop gossip about her daughter Charlotteâs (Hannah Shealy) impending divorce.
In a rare alliance, Mrs. Astor joins forces with Agnes, Ada (Cynthia Nixon), Bertha, and Mrs. Fish to exile McAllister from society. First, heâs uninvited from Mrs. Astorâs party; then, heâs denied entry to her home. Still, McAllister barges in, insisting, âI made society what it is,â citing his creation of the Four Hundred and importing European sophistication. Mrs. Astor refuses to relent, telling him he had no right to humiliate their circle.
Later, a chastened McAllister confides to Bertha that he simply wanted to show societyâs members as ânormal people.â But his ego clouded his judgment â and it cost him everything.
How the Real Ward McAllisterâs Scandal Played Out
The real Ward McAllister was every bit as influential as the show depicts. Partnering with Mrs. Astor, he defined the Four Hundred â a list of New Yorkâs most prominent families â and shaped the cityâs social calendar.
But in 1890, when McAllister published “Society As I Have Found It,” he alienated the very people who had propped him up. Like his fictional counterpart, he used initials instead of names, but the identities were obvious. His harshest offense? Discussing the financial habits of the elite, rather than their gossip, in a way that invited public scrutiny.
The New York Timesâ October 19, 1890, review pulled no punches:
âThe degree of fervor that the author puts into undertakings that adults commonly leave to adolescents is really wonderful.â
âNo suspicion that he is making a continental laughingstock of himself must disturb his mindâ¦it would be fatal to him.â
Though McAllister remained socially active â even founding an exclusive club that hosted lavish balls in the early 1890s â his access to the true power players was gone. By the time he died in 1895, Mrs. Astor didnât attend his funeral, claiming a prior engagement. A fellow club member summed it up bluntly: âPoor McAllister. What a pity he wrote a book!â
“The Gilded Age” season 3 finale airs Sunday, August 10, on HBO and HBO Max
The post This ‘Gilded Age’ Character’s Real-Life Scandal Was Even Wilder Than the Show appeared first on EntertainmentNow.