Editorial: California election results offered no surprises

Republicans nationwide are licking their wounds — and beginning the usual recriminations — after Democrats decisively grabbed control of the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate, scored major gubernatorial upsets and pretty much ran up the score even in the unlikeliest of places, such as Texas and South Carolina.

The message was clear. This was a rebuke of the president, the Republican Party and the MAGA movement. In California, however, the message was muddled. Certainly, Democrats here surged to major victories by claiming all the statewide offices and picking up almost all of the seats in the newly gerrymandered congressional districts. But this was par for the course, as Republicans haven’t been in the running for many years.

Democrat Xavier Becerra bested Republican Steve Hilton in the governor’s race, which the networks called immediately. The latest tally is 64% to 36%, which is somewhat worse than 2022 when Gavin Newsom beat Brian Dahle, 59% to 41%. In 2018, Newsom beat John Cox, 62% to 38%. In 2010, Jerry Brown beat Meg Whitman by a mere 13 points. So the numbers keep getting worse.

Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger was the last Republican to win the governorship 20 years ago. Likewise, the last time Republicans held any statewide elected office was 2011 when Steve Poizner was insurance commissioner. The other statewide offices this year paint a similar picture, with almost all the GOP statewide candidates posting similar numbers to Hilton’s. The only exception was superintendent of public instruction candidate Sonja Shaw (down by 14 points), but that’s a nonpartisan race.

So voters didn’t send any resounding message regarding candidates, but they echoed what they’ve been saying for years: They don’t like the GOP. We’d suggest that Republicans do some soul-searching, but they’ve been searching for years and it’s not yet obvious what they can do to rebound. 

In the one Democrat v. Democrat statewide race, former San Francisco Supervisor Jane Kim is leading state Senator Ben Allen for insurance commissioner. That’s a troubling result given Allen was committed to continuing reforms that are slowly fixing California’s insurance crisis, whereas Kim wants the state to take over parts of the private insurance industry. That race may signal voters’ willingness to edge in a democratic-socialist direction.

Regarding the initiatives, California voters stayed true to form by approving new spending but rejecting some of the more aggressive left-leaning measures. Most significantly, they rejected the billionaires’ tax, Proposition 40, 55% to 45%. That was a win for common sense. They also seem to have approved Proposition 42, which prohibits such tax measures in the future. 

On the unfortunate side, voters rejected a major CEQA reform measure backed by the California Chamber of Commerce (Proposition 45) by a solid margin. It was a perfectly reasonable measure, but was drowned in hysteria about data centers somehow benefiting from the measure. Voters also rejected Proposition 43, which would have limited local tax increases by affirming that the vote threshold for special taxes is two-thirds.

Voter ID (Proposition 39) has gone down to defeat, also. That’s no surprise given that it was tainted by Republican voter-integrity claims. We endorsed it, but aren’t heartbroken given that there’s no evidence of mass voter fraud in California’s elections. Voters also approved a series of questionable bond measures that will run up debt for projects that are unnecessary and would have been better funded through the budget process. 

While the nation sorts through the election entrails, Californians will shrug at business as usual.  

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *