Jurors were handed the case Friday, May 29, against five reputed gang members — some of whom are charged in the killing of a man during a robbery at a lookout along Angeles Crest Highway and others charged in the shooting deaths of two people inside a parked car during an attempted hold-up at a lookout in Rancho Palos Verdes two days later.
“This case is about coordinated violence, purposeful violence and predatory violence,” Deputy District Attorney Hilary Williams told jurors as closing arguments began Wednesday. “They hunted together, they robbed together, they killed together.”
Defense attorneys, meanwhile, urged the downtown Los Angeles jury to acquit the five of the most serious charges of murder.
Jurors spent just over an hour in deliberations Friday afternoon and are due back in a downtown Los Angeles courtroom Monday to resume their discussion about the case.
Marco Antonio Hernandez, 21, is charged with three counts of murder in connection with the July 22, 2023, killing of Jesse Munoz along Angeles Crest Highway and the July 24, 2023, deaths of Jorge Ramos and Taylor Raven Whittaker, who were shot inside a parked Subaru in the 7000 block of Palos Verdes Drive.
Abraham Ernesto Alvarenga Cortez, 23, and Luis Ventura, 27, are charged along with Hernandez in the killing of Munoz, and Rossel Jose Hernandez-Ponce, 24, and Wendy Sarai Cerritos, 23, are charged along with Hernandez in the killings of Ramos and Whittaker.
Munoz was sitting in his car with a female friend in a “perfect place to come upon unsuspecting victims and rob them,” with the group acting as a “pack” outnumbering and robbing the two before Cortez fired at Munoz as the victim tried to back his vehicle out, according to the prosecutor, who said the victim’s vehicle wound up on top of a guardrail.
The deputy district attorney noted that Cortez told an undercover operative in jail following his arrest that “I shot him three times.”
The same gun was used two days later at the lookout in Rancho Palos Verdes, with Hernandez-Ponce firing the shots that killed Ramos and Whittaker and Hernandez firing multiple times without striking the victims, according to the prosecutor.
Cerritos — whom the prosecution alleges was the getaway driver — chose the “very remote” location, got out of her Toyota Scion and communicated with Hernandez-Ponce that there were two people in the victims’ vehicle, then watched as her compatriots got out of her car and surrounded the victims’ vehicle, the deputy district attorney told the jury.
“No one pressured her to do this. She is just as involved as everyone else,” Williams said, urging jurors not to let the young woman’s youthful look “fool you.”
The deputy district attorney called the crimes “calculated terror” and urged the panel to “hold these gang members accountable and responsible for their actions.”
In his closing argument, Hernandez’s attorney, Damon Hobdy, called question to the murder charge against his client for Munoz’s killing, arguing that he didn’t plan the crime, supply a gun or do anything other than driving the getaway vehicle.
He said jurors needed more evidence than his client’s admission to shooting into the Subaru in Rancho Palos Verdes, urging the panel to “make your decision based on the evidence.”
Alvarenga Cortez’s lawyer, Anthony Arzili, questioned the accounts of two key prosecution witnesses and asked jurors to acquit his client. He said the young man was in the U.S. without any family and was homeless at the time.
Defense attorney Simon Aval said he didn’t know why Ventura was charged with murder, noting that “my client didn’t shoot anybody.”
“They’re trying to get five murder convictions and stretching the law,” he said.
Hernandez-Ponce’s attorney, Michael Waldinger, noted that the jurors have heard “confessions” and “admissions,” but said that is “not enough.”
“I’m asking you all to do something that is so, so difficult,” he said. “Look at this case … find that the prosecution hasn’t proved their case.”
Laurice Y. Cheung, representing Cerritos, described her client and Hernandez-Ponce as being “at a minimum infatuated with each other, possibly in love,” and said the young woman was “wanting to fit in in his world.”
The defense attorney said Cerritos only realized that real firearms were being used in the Rancho Palos Verdes attack after she heard the gunfire, and said that she was “scared” and quickly drove away upon being told to do so when the men returned to her car after the shooting.
In her rebuttal argument, Deputy District Attorney Carmelia Mejia urged jurors to convict each of the defendants, arguing that the victims “should all be on this planet,” but that the defendants “stole their lives.”
Hernandez and Hernandez-Ponce are also facing the special circumstance allegations of multiple murders and murder during the commission of a robbery or attempted robbery, while Alvarenga Cortez and Cerritos are facing the special circumstance allegation of murder during the commission of a robbery or attempted robbery.
The charges also include allegations that Hernandez, Hernandez-Ponce and Alvarenga Cortez personally used a firearm.
The Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office opted not to seek the death penalty against the four, who could face life in prison without the possibility of parole if convicted as charged. Ventura is not facing any special circumstance allegations.
Hernandez, Alvarenga Cortez and Ventura are also facing two counts of robbery involving the Angeles Crest Highway attack, while Hernandez, Hernandez- Ponce and Cerritos are charged with two counts of attempted robbery involving the Rancho Palos Verdes attack.
All five defendants are also charged with one count each of conspiracy to commit robbery.
They have remained behind bars since their arrests in the summer of 2023, jail records show.