A swapping of former New York Jets quarterbacks has just taken place.
The Tennessee Titans have signed Trevor Siemian and waived passer Tim Boyle in a corresponding move, Insider Jim Wyatt revealed.
The @Titans have signed QB Trevor Siemian and waived QB Tim Boyle.
Also, center Lloyd Cushenberry has passed his physical and is being activated from PUP.
STORY https://t.co/TI7dbRL7O3 pic.twitter.com/8KfhQc55Ah
— Jim Wyatt (@jwyattsports) August 11, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Tennessee got blown out in their preseason opener, 29-7, against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Boyle was the third quarterback on the field for the Titans. He operated the final four drives of the game.
Those four drives resulted in a punt, another punt, an interception, and a pick-six.
“Titans QB Tim Boyle tonight: 4-for-13, 24 yards, 2 INTs, 0.6 passer rating,” FOX NFL Insider Greg Auman posted on social media.
Titans QB Tim Boyle tonight: 4-for-13, 24 yards, 2 INTs, 0.6 passer rating
— Greg Auman (@gregauman) August 10, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Social Media Reacts to Boyle’s Unique Performance
Out of 90 QBs that played in the preseason, Boyle ranked No. 89 in passer rating and No. 84 in completion percentage, per CBS Sports via radio host Zach Lyons.
According to @CBSSports, out of 90 QBs that played in the Preseason, here’s where the #Titans backups ranked in terms of
Passer Rating:
• Brandon Allen: 80th
• Tim Boyle: 89thComp %:
• Brandon Allen: 70th
• Tim Boyle: 84th— Zach Lyons (@TheZachLyons) August 11, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
“Nah, Drew Lock belongs in the league, just not starting. Now, Tim Boyle…THAT’s someone who has to have dirt on people to still be cashing NFL paychecks,” Irish NFL analyst Sam Monson said on X previously Twitter.
Nah, Drew Lock belongs in the league, just not starting.
Now, Tim Boyle…THAT’s someone who has to have dirt on people to still be cashing NFL paychecks. https://t.co/MSg5YJcMz3
— Sam Monson (@SamMonsonNFL) August 8, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
“Tim Boyle has to be a con artist. This is Frank Abagnale level stuff. How has a guy with that college career lasted 6 years in the NFL? This man has made EIGHT MILLION DOLLARS,” NFL analyst Nick Lombardi posted.
Tim Boyle has to be a con artist. This is Frank Abagnale level stuff. How has a guy with that college career lasted 6 years in the NFL?
This man has made EIGHT MILLION DOLLARS pic.twitter.com/k55AXyBPnx
— Nick Lombardi (@NF_Lombardi) August 10, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
According to Spotrac, Boyle has made $8.22 million in career earnings during his NFL career.
“Tim Boyle is the worst football player I’ve ever seen,” a Titans analyst said on social media.
Tim Boyle is the worst football player I’ve ever seen
— Evan (@titan_insider23) August 10, 2025
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
A Snapshot of the Jets’ Troubled History at the QB Position
Boyle, 30, left a bad taste in Jets fans’ mouths.
After Aaron Rodgers blew out his Achilles in the 2023 season opener, the Jets went through a lot of different players at the QB position.
Boyle was one of those names. During that season, he appeared in three games and made two starts.
The first start resulted in one of the worst plays in NFL history.
Gang Green was down 10-6 to the Miami Dolphins on the first-ever Black Friday NFL game on Thanksgiving weekend. There were two seconds left on the game clock in the first half with the Jets at the 50-yard line.
Boyle chucked it toward the end zone for a Hail Mary attempt. Instead of finding a Jets player, he found then Dolphins safety Jevon Holland, who returned it 99 yards to the house for a touchdown.
Here’s Jets QB Tim Boyle throwing a hail mary pick-six.
“Can you believe this?! That is insanity! That’s as crazy as anything you’ll ever see!”- Al Michaels
“If there’s ever a play that embodies an entire season, this is it for the New York Jets.”- Kirk Herbstreit pic.twitter.com/b06dLZS7W3
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 24, 2023
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
“I can not believe what I just saw. A 99-yard Hail Mary Pick Six. Tim Boyle’s first TD pass as a Jet,” NFL Network’s Rich Eisen reacted.
I can not believe what I just saw.
A 99-yard Hail Mary Pick Six.
Tim Boyle’s first TD pass as a Jet.
— Rich Eisen (@richeisen) November 24, 2023
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Siemian’s History With the Jets Isn’t Much Better
In 2019, the Jets thought they had their franchise quarterback with Sam Darnold. During the season opener, the Jets led 16-0 over the Buffalo Bills.
Gang Green collapsed in the second half and ended up losing 17-16. Following the game, the football Gods added insult to injury.
Darnold had contracted mononucleosis and was ruled out “indefinitely.” So heading into Week 2, the Jets turned to Siemian for a Monday Night Football game against the Cleveland Browns.
Halfway through the second quarter of that game, Browns superstar pass rusher Myles Garrett sacked Siemian. During the play, Siemian’s ankle snapped, tearing “multiple ligaments” ending his season.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Titans Dump Ex-Jets QB After Historically Inept Preseason Performance appeared first on Heavy Sports.