With MLB All-Star voting heating up, San Diego Padres’ passionate broadcaster Mark Grant brought the debate center stage.
As Manny Machado and Los Angeles Dodgers slugger Max Muncy battle for the National League’s starting third base spot, Grant’s on-air remark reflects both the Padres’ confidence in their star and the broader rivalry between San Diego and L.A.
Machado vs. Muncy In 2025
Machado, a six-time All-Star and one of the league’s most consistent defensive infielders, is once again making a strong case to start at third. While his offensive numbers aren’t as loud as Muncy’s home run totals, Machado’s all-around value — glove, leadership, and consistency — is tough to ignore.
Muncy, for his part, brings power to the Dodgers’ lineup but isn’t known for elite defense. He’s also benefited from Los Angeles’ larger market and team success when it comes to national recognition. But reading between Grant’s lines, if you’re voting based on who plays the position better, Machado deserves the edge.
The third base voting battle has become one of the most tightly contested races in the National League. Machado’s presence as the Padres’ lone finalist underscores how much weight he carries in San Diego. Muncy, meanwhile, is one of several Dodgers finalists, joining Freddie Freeman, Mookie Betts, and others in a stacked ballot showing.
Padres-Dodgers Tension Extends to the Ballot
The Padres’ rivalry with the Dodgers has never needed much fuel. But this year’s All-Star vote adds another layer. Machado and Muncy are longtime division opponents, and with both healthy and producing, their head-to-head in fan voting matters.
Machado’s supporters have pointed to his defensive impact and leadership. Others argue Muncy’s power numbers and ability to change a game with one swing make him the more “explosive” option.
But for broadcasters like Grant and many within the Padres organization, the debate isn’t close.
This isn’t just about starting a game in July. For Machado, securing an All-Star start would mark his seventh career appearance and another moment of validation in a season where he’s had to carry much of the load.
With Fernando Tatis Jr., Xander Bogaerts, and Jackson Merrill failing to land among the ballot finalists, Machado stands alone — both literally and figuratively — as San Diego’s clearest All-Star hopeful.
The Dodgers, on the other hand, are dominating the ballot. If Muncy wins the fan vote, it’ll be one more notch in L.A.’s consistent edge in visibility, influence, and reach.
But there’s still time. Fan voting remains open, and the race at third base is close. For Padres fans, it’s a chance to rally around their guy — and remind the league that not all stars wear Dodger blue.
Regardless of who gets the nod, this vote highlights how much rivalry, reputation, and reach influence All-Star decisions. And in a season where the Padres are still fighting to stay in the playoff hunt, any boost — especially in the form of league recognition — matters.
Machado may not be leading the league in home runs. But in the eyes of many — including his own broadcaster — he’s still the best third baseman in the National League.
And now, it’s up to the fans to decide if they agree.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Padres Broadcaster Sounds Off On Manny Machado All-Star Disrespect appeared first on Heavy Sports.