The New York Yankees brought back Luis Gil on Sunday, hoping for a spark. Instead, they got another flashing red warning sign that their rotation plan might already be unraveling.
Activated off the 60-day injured list and making his long-awaited season debut, Gil gave up five earned runs in just 3.1 innings against the Miami Marlins, looking every bit like a pitcher not yet ready for the moment—or the workload. The Yankees dropped the series finale by getting swept by the Marlins, the first time in franchise history. The decision to pass on starting pitching at the trade deadline now looms even larger.
Gil Lights Up the Radar Gun—And the Scoreboard
The velocity was there. According to Statcast, Gil’s fastball topped out at 98.5 mph and averaged 96.4, while his changeup sat near 92 and his slider flashed 87 with elite spin (2,690 rpm). He even produced the hardest-hit ball of the day—unfortunately, it came off a Marlins bat at 111.2 mph.
Despite the heat, the command simply wasn’t there. Gil walked four batters, allowed five hits, and needed 77 pitches to record just 10 outs. His outing ended with the Yankees down 3–1, and he left the mound with a 13.50 ERA on the season. 13 of the 77 pitches he threw were hit at 95+ mph exit velocity. His four-seamer was crushed, averaging nearly 98 mph off the bat, and his slider—though sharp—missed the zone far too often to be effective.
The whiffs were limited (just five on 31 swings), and while Gil avoided the longball, the Marlins consistently made loud contact and worked deep counts. It was a rough welcome back to The Show, and a reminder of how volatile upside can be without consistency.
Yankees Bet Big on Gil—And It’s Already Backfiring
When the Yankees stood pat at the trade deadline and didn’t acquire a starting pitcher, they made one thing clear: they were counting on Luis Gil to be their midseason addition.
That decision now looks like a gamble they couldn’t afford.
Rather than trading for rotation depth—or holding onto veteran Marcus Stroman, whom they released just days earlier—the Yankees chose to roll with Gil, Will Warren, and Cam Schlittler behind Max Fried and Carlos Rodón. It’s a rotation plan stitched together by potential and hope. But hope isn’t a strategy.
For all his inconsistencies, Stroman had 193.2 innings of experience in a Yankees uniform. Gil has 10 starts since 2022. Injuries and erratic command have stalled his development, and while the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year showed flashes last season, his 12.1% walk rate raised red flags that never truly disappeared.
With Clarke Schmidt out for the year, Gerrit Cole still sidelined, and Jonathan Loáisiga hitting the IL again, the Yankees are running out of options. And fast.
After three straight losses to the Marlins—including one where they scored 12 runs and still lost—it’s clear the Yankees’ margin for error is razor-thin. Their elite bullpen can’t fix everything. And if Gil doesn’t round into form quickly, this team may not have enough innings to survive the stretch run.
Sunday’s start was supposed to be a return to form. Instead, it was a rude awakening.
Luis Gil has talent. But if the Yankees want to stay afloat, they’ll need more than spin rate and radar gun readings.
They’ll need results. And fast.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Yankees Counted on This Pitcher—He Didn’t Make It Out of the Fourth appeared first on Heavy Sports.