The New York Yankees spent the summer trying to squeeze the last bit of value out of Paul Goldschmidt. By early September, the calculus changed. A bone bruise in his knee and weeks of diminishing impact nudged the former MVP into a short-side platoon, with Ben Rice taking the bulk of starts at first base. Now comes the natural endpoint: national outlets predict Goldschmidt won’t be back in the Bronx in 2026, and a familiar landing spot awaits.
Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter slotted Goldschmidt as Arizona’s placeholder at first base in his way-too-early 2026 Opening Day projections, citing the Diamondbacks’ internal options (namely Tyler Locklear) falling flat since midseason. In other words: Arizona needs competence at first while it retools; Goldschmidt needs reps and comfort to close out a likely Hall of Fame career. That Venn diagram overlaps in Phoenix.
A Short-Side Platoon, Then The Exit
The Yankees didn’t arrive here by accident. Goldschmidt’s scorching April (.365 at one point) masked a steady slide that pushed him into a role tailored almost exclusively for left-handed pitching. The knee issue—a low-grade sprain in mid-August followed by a bone bruise—tightened the screws: he was emergency-only for at least one game, then eased back with reduced usage as Rice seized the everyday runway. That’s not a bridge to a new contract; it’s a runway toward a clean break.
Newsweek connected those dots Tuesday, noting that the injury and decline have turned Goldschmidt into a situational option and amplifying Reuter’s Arizona projection. It matches what the depth chart already says out loud. Rice’s emergence gives New York low-cost production and a left-handed bat that fits Yankee Stadium. Carrying a 37-year-old righty 1B as a premium bench piece in 2026 isn’t how this front office allocates dollars, not with needs in the rotation and late-inning relief.
Why Arizona Makes Sense
For the D-Backs, the sell is simple: stability. Reuter pointed out Locklear’s swing-and-miss spike after the Eugenio Suárez trade, a data point that underscores Arizona’s need to shop outside the org for 2026. Even a one-year pact with Goldschmidt buys development time while insulating the lineup against a position that cratered during their transition. The clubhouse fit is obvious, too. Goldschmidt’s six All-Star nods, three Gold Gloves and four Silver Sluggers came in the desert; a soft-landing encore in a DH-light role makes more sense there than in the Bronx, where expectations and roster math are less forgiving.
From the Yankees’ side, the final weeks have looked like organizational triage: protect the bat when the matchup favors it, protect the player when the knee flares, and keep innings open for Rice. Multiple injury updates stressed clean imaging and day-to-day management—fine news for September, but not a forecast for a new deal. If anything, they reinforced that this relationship was winding down on the field even before the rumor mill started printing mock lineups.
New York didn’t need a prediction to know where this was headed. They were already moving off Goldschmidt, and the depth chart told the truth long before the headlines did. If he gets one more everyday shot in 2026, it’s far likelier to be in the desert than under the Bronx lights, a tidy ending that serves both sides’ realities.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Yankees’ Infielder Predicted to Rejoin Old Team After 2025 Season appeared first on Heavy Sports.