Cavaliers’ Record Shattering Payroll Sets Stage for Make-or-Break Season

The Cleveland Cavaliers aren’t just spending big—they’re betting their entire future on it.

Cleveland enters the 2025–26 NBA season leading the league with a record-shattering $392.4 million total payroll, including a staggering $163.8 million luxury tax bill. Their base salary number of $228.6 million is roughly $23 million higher than any other team. It’s a bold, all-in commitment that signals one thing: the time to win is now.

A Massive Financial Gamble

The Cavaliers are the only team currently above the league’s second-apron tax threshold, a line that restricts flexibility and limits future roster moves. Yet, this didn’t stop them from doubling down on their core.

Last summer, Donovan Mitchell inked a three-year, $150.3 million extension, keeping him in Cleveland through at least 2028. Around the same time, Evan Mobley’s five-year, $269.1 million deal hit the books. Add in Darius Garland’s escalating contract through 2028 and Jarrett Allen’s steady $20 million annual salary, and Cleveland’s “Core Four” now commands $152 million combined this season—more than the entire payrolls of some rebuilding teams.

It’s the highest cost ever to keep a non-championship roster intact. But for a franchise still chasing its first post-LeBron Finals appearance, the Cavaliers believe the investment could finally push them over the top.

The Stakes Couldn’t Be Higher

Cleveland finished last season with a franchise-best 64 wins, but fell short in the second round to Indiana. That early exit underscored the stakes: regular-season dominance isn’t enough anymore.

Now, the Cavs enter a weaker Eastern Conference, with injuries sidelining stars on contenders like Boston and Indiana. Analysts project them as legitimate title threats—but also as one of the league’s most pressurized teams.

If Cleveland can’t reach the Eastern Conference Finals, questions will mount about the sustainability of their spending. The second apron severely limits midseason adjustments, meaning this group must win largely as-is.

A Defining Year for the Core Four

Mitchell’s extension came with a player option in 2027–28—one that gives him the flexibility to reassess his future. Mobley is locked in long term, but Garland and Allen are viewed around the league as the more tradable pieces, both on manageable contracts that expire within the next three years.

That dynamic creates a sense of urgency. This could be the Cavaliers’ best—and possibly last—real shot to prove their current core can contend. Anything less than a deep playoff run could force the front office to consider breaking up the roster and resetting the financial balance sheet.

Going All In or Going Out

While big-market franchises like the Warriors, Knicks, and Lakers sit near the top of payroll rankings, Cleveland now leads them all—by nearly $120 million. It’s an astonishing figure for a small-market team that’s chosen ambition over caution.

For owner Dan Gilbert and the Cavaliers’ front office, the message is clear: money won’t be the excuse. The franchise has invested at a level few could have imagined even five years ago.

Now, it’s up to Mitchell, Mobley, Garland, and Allen to make it worth every penny.

The Cavaliers aren’t just spending to compete—they’re spending to define their era. And in a make-or-break season with historic financial stakes, there’s no middle ground left between triumph and disappointment.

Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.

This article was originally published on Heavy Sports

The post Cavaliers’ Record Shattering Payroll Sets Stage for Make-or-Break Season appeared first on Heavy Sports.