As we move into the holiday season with its familiar messages of peace and goodwill, it is worth pausing to hear a powerful warning from American faith leaders about the Trump administration’s government-sanctioned cruelty toward immigrants.
The U.S. Catholic Bishops’ recent “special statement” on immigrants is an important moral intervention in our time. Our history shows that when faith communities speak with moral clarity about social crises, it often precedes the moment when political leaders finally wake up.
This has been true from the pulpits before the American Revolution to the abolitionists, the Social Gospel reformers, the civil-rights clergy and the anti-war pastors of the Vietnam era. In each case, the nation stood at a turning point.
The bishops’ message today is plain and urgent. They condemn “indiscriminate mass deportation,” call out the “vilification of immigrants,” and assure those suffering that “you are not alone.” They urge Catholics to welcome immigrants, support ministries that aid them, reject dehumanizing rhetoric, and defend the God-given dignity of every person.
This is a moral alarm bell, the kind America has long relied upon, usually arriving before political leaders finally find their courage.
History provides the pattern. Before the Revolution, ministers who had fled tyranny understood how easily power could twist religion into oppression. When Boston’s Rev. Jonathan Mayhew declared in 1750 that “resistance to tyranny is obedience to God,” he warned a people who would soon fight for their freedom. John Adams later called Mayhew’s preaching “the spark that ignited the American Revolution.”
The bishops’ letter stands in that same tradition, a clear statement that human dignity is being violated and fear is becoming policy.
And today, as in earlier moments of crisis, faith leaders are already paying a price for speaking truth. In Chicago, Presbyterian minister David Black was struck in the head by a pepper ball fired by an ICE agent while he led prayer at a protest. Here in the East Bay, Rev. Jorge Bautista, a pastor at United Church of Christ congregation in San Mateo, was shot in the face with a pepper round during protests at the entrance to Coast Guard Island, which lies between Alameda and Oakland.
Their courage underscores what the bishops are saying: this is a moral emergency, not a routine policy dispute.
We have seen this pattern before.
The Social Gospel movement challenged the greed and abuses of the Gilded Age long before Theodore and Franklin Roosevelt acted. Martin Luther King Jr. denounced segregation years before Congress passed the Civil Rights Act. During the Vietnam War, clergy called the conflict immoral long before most elected officials dared speak.
In America, moral awakenings come before political ones.
We are in such an awakening now. A major political faction has chosen power over principle and cruelty over compassion. The bishops’ statement cuts through the noise. It is not partisan. It is moral. It reminds us that a nation is judged by how it treats the vulnerable, not by how loudly it celebrates the powerful.
The message is simple. Immigrants are human beings. They are neighbors. They must not be abandoned. By insisting on dignity, welcome, dialogue, and reform — the bishops reclaim a deep American tradition, faith leaders speaking up when too many others remain silent.
Their statement matters because it names what is happening, adds to restoring a missing moral voice in public life, and calls us back to conscience. This is the first step toward justice.
As we celebrate a season devoted to peace and compassion, the bishops have stepped into the light. The question now is whether the rest of us will follow.
Tom Debley is a retired East Bay journalist and public affairs officer. He lives in Walnut Creek.