The truth is Superman has been rebooted more times than your Wi-Fi router. Every few years, Hollywood tosses him back on the big screen like this will finally be the one to nail it. But while the movies keep fumbling the ball somewhere between alien messiah and sad farm boy, âSuperman & Loisâ quietly delivered the version of Clark Kent fans had been waiting for: layered, grounded, and (gasp) actually relatable to humans.
Superman Deserves More Than Just a Two-Hour Time Limit
The CW’s âSuperman & Lois” doesn’t just give us the man in the cape. It gives us a husband, a father, a dude navigating the chaos of modern life and supervillains. And because itâs a series, not a two-hour event with 20 minutes of slow-mo cape shots (even though they are amazing), it actually gets time to breathe. The show leans into the family dynamic, the heartache, the small victories, and yeah, the world-ending threats too⦠but without sacrificing the character for CGI set pieces.
The CWOne fan nailed it when they said, “I think it’s the best live action adaptation of Superman we’ve ever gotten. Superman is a farmboy, a nerd, paternal, communal, powerful, thoughtful and instead of being checked by whatever else filmmakers use, he’s checked by his care for his family and friends, his responsibility to Earth, his stringent morals.” Thatâs the heart of the show; Superman isnât Superman in spite of his humanity; heâs Superman because of it.
Why This Version Works â And Keeps Working
Unlike the movie versions, which often reset Clark to âlonely alien still figuring it out,â this series embraces the idea that Superman can grow up. Heâs not just a boy from Smallville anymore, (even though he might be living there). Instead, heâs raising his own teenagers, balancing marriage with saving the planet, and trying to hold onto his identity without letting the cape define him.
Sure, some might say, “Yeah, it has the typical CW drama, but the action scenes, the themes, the emotional depth, the acting, the villains, even the side characters, are all amazing and top-notch,â like this fan on Reddit did. And theyâre not wrong. The showâs writing wasnât always perfect (RIP to some of those random arcs), but when it works, it really works.
GettyAnd when it comes to action? Another viewer summed it up perfectly: “The season 3 finale fight was balls out crazy, and I loved it. Possibly my favorite Superman fight scene ever put to film.” Thatâs high praise; and honestly, deserved.
The performances also get a major thumbs up from fans. “This may be a hot take, but I think Tyler Hoechlin and Elizabeth Tulloch are the best Superman and Lois actors in the last several decades. They capture the characters PERFECTLY,” said one commenter. Not just believable; they made these iconic roles feel lived-in, natural, and emotionally resonant.
The End of a Great Chapter
Even for longtime Superman fans, this series struck a chord in a way other adaptations have not. “My favorite Superman in a long time. I liked Cavill, but his movies didn’t wow me,” one person said.
“Superman & Lois” officially ended in 2024 with season 4 and it was a bittersweet goodbye. But if you ask fans what live-action Superman story felt the most complete, most lived-in, and most honest to the character? The CW still takes the crown.
Only time will tell if that changes, especially with more Superman reboots in the pipeline. But for now? “Superman & Lois” is still the one to beat.
The post Is the Best Superman Story Already Behind Us? Some Fans Think So appeared first on EntertainmentNow.