University sports, have long been a field of passion, competition, and intense loyalty. Yet beneath the surface of packed stadiums and thrilling games lies a chaotic, poorly regulated, and rapidly evolving landscape that closely resembles the Wild West of the 19th century. This comparison is not merely insightful; it highlights deep issues around governance, money, power, and freedom that define the current state of college sports.
The Wild West was known for its absence of centralized authority, where law enforcement was sparse and rules were often made or broken on the spot. Similarly, today, college athletics operates in a murky zone, where governance is fragmented and enforcement is inconsistent.
The NCAA has traditionally been the main regulatory body, but its rules are often outdated, contradictory, and selectively enforced. Recent developments, including Supreme Court decisions, have complicated the regulatory environment. Schools, conferences, and even states are creating their own rules, leading to a patchwork system with little national uniformity.
Like the Wild West, this regulatory confusion creates opportunities for exploitation and controversy. Some schools and athletes benefit from loopholes and aggressive interpretations of these guidelines, while others are penalized inconsistently. The lack of clear, enforceable rules creates turf wars among schools, agents, and sponsors, all competing for advantage.
The Wild West was fueled by the gold rush — a frenzy for wealth that attracted prospectors, businessmen, and opportunists. College athletics today is driven by a similar rush for revenue and influence.
Major college sports, especially football and basketball, generate billions of dollars annually through media agreements, merchandising, institutional support, student fees, ticket sales, booster donations and sponsorships. Universities see athletics as a lucrative branding and fundraising tool, while coaches command multimillion-dollar salaries: some over $10 million annually.
This gold rush creates intense competition and sometimes ruthless behavior. Schools invest heavily in facilities, direct compensation to athletes, and recruiting to gain a competitive edge. Coaches and agents maneuver aggressively to secure top talent. Young athletes must navigate complex contracts with little or no legal and financial advice.
In today’s sports environment, ethical boundaries can be unclear or ignored, reminiscent of the lawlessness and opportunism of the Wild West. Scandals involving recruiting violations, tampering with other school’s players, academic deception, and dishonest compensation are common, and the stakes have never been higher.
The Wild West was a place of both opportunity and danger, where settlers could build new lives but faced unpredictable threats. College athletes today inhabit a similar frontier.
For many players, college sports offer a chance to showcase their talents, earn scholarships, earn million-dollar direct compensation and potentially launch professional careers. Recent court decisions have opened new territory for athletes to monetize their fame while still in school, and generous transfer policies are a revolutionary shift from previous eras.
Arch Manning has a name, image and likeness valuation of an estimated $6.8 million. The Texas Longhorns’ quarterback signed a deal with Red Bull in January and has a company peddling autographs on his behalf. Carson Beck who is now with the University of Miami after using the transfer portal to leave Georgia, is valued at $4.3 million, and Jeremiah Smith, studying at Ohio State University, is a close third in the league, worth an esitmated $4.2 million.
However, these opportunities come with serious risks. Many athletes face intense pressure to perform while balancing academics and their personal lives. Injuries can end careers abruptly. Athletes can suffer Long-term health impacts, particularly in football, where repeated hits can lead to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) later in life. The lack of comprehensive protections and support systems for athletes echoes the Wild West’s perilous landscape, where pioneers often had to fend for themselves amid uncertainty and danger.
In the Wild West, mavericks, often rebellious individuals — played enormous roles. Today’s college athletics landscape features similar figures: Deion Sanders (University of Colorado) is known for his charismatic personality, unique recruiting style, and emphasis on culture change; Mario Cristobal (University of Miami) is an aggressive recruiter with a brash style, known for his strong emphasis on physicality and toughness; and Brent Venables (University of Oklahoma) is a defensive mastermind bringing innovative schemes and a fiery coaching demeanor.
With the recent emergence of mandated pay-for-play, individual athletes have become entrepreneurs. They also have the autonomy to sign endorsement contracts for their personal brands in ways previously unimaginable. Meanwhile, independent sports agents, coaches, and marketing firms aggressively recruit talent, sometimes clashing with schools and the NCAA.
Boosters and donors also act as powerful, sometimes shadowy players. Their financial support can sway recruiting and program decisions.
The Wild West was often tainted by territorial disputes and rivalries, often settled through showdowns or alliances. College athletics mirrors this dynamic through intense rivalries not just on the field but in recruitment, conference realignment, and media markets.
Schools compete fiercely to sign top recruits, sometimes engaging in unethical gray areas. Conferences are reshaping themselves based on media revenue, streaming platforms potential, rather than geography, game start times or tradition, leading to shifting allegiances and tensions.
These turf wars create a volatile environment where alliances can shift quickly, power balances change, and uncertainty reigns.
College athletics is undeniably a modern-day Wild West — a frontier of opportunity, risk, money, and power, shaped by fragmented rules and fierce competition. Like the frontier towns of old, it is a place where fortunes can be made or lost, where law and order struggle to keep pace with rapid change, and where students navigate a complex landscape of alliances and rivalries.
Understanding college athletics through this lens helps explain its current challenges and the urgent need for reform. Clearer regulation, better protections for athletes, transparency in financial dealings, and a balanced approach to governance could help tame this wild frontier.
Until then, college sports will remain a thrilling yet unpredictable field — where legends are made, fortunes are chased, dreams are lost and the spirit of the Wild West lives on.
The wild, wild West often occurred when there was no sheriff in town.
College sports now more than ever needs a modern-day sheriff to supervise present outlaws like Billy the Kid and pioneers like Buffalo Bill.
Jim Martin was an adjunct professor who taught Sports Law at CU and DU-chaired the University of Colorado committee on athletics for many years and has a passion for public speaking engagements. He can be reached at jimmartinesq@gmail.com.
Sign up for Sound Off to get a weekly roundup of our columns, editorials and more.
To send a letter to the editor about this article, submit online or check out our guidelines for how to submit by email or mail.