Susan Shelley’s critique of Allan Lichtman’s “13 Keys to the White House” misinterprets his framework. Lichtman, with a proven record, defined the criteria, so claiming he’s “wrong” is misguided.
For Key 3 (no serious contest for the incumbent), Shelley argues the Democratic primary was contested because Kamala Harris took over after Biden stepped down. But the party overwhelmingly rallied behind her, which aligns with Lichtman’s definition.
On Key 8 (civil unrest), Shelley points to protests and social tensions, but Lichtman defines unrest as sustained instability during the election. While unrest exists, it doesn’t meet that threshold.
Finally, Key 13 (the challenger is uncharismatic): Trump excites his base, but Lichtman’s definition requires broad appeal, which Trump lacks. Harris, however, may fit the bill.
Shelley’s deviations from Lichtman’s definitions weaken her critique. Therefore, Harris is poised to become the first woman of mixed race to shatter the ultimate glass ceiling in American politics.
Elaine Neff, Mission Hills
Letter: Trump is the fighter America needs
Letter: Ronald Reagan actually was great, Larry Wilson and Max Boot are wrong
Letter: Trump exaggerates when he speaks, but he has the right ideas to fix America’s problems
Letter: Trump supporters like his way of speaking but don’t want us to take him seriously
Letter: Kamala Harris deserves credit for at least going on Fox News
Related Posts:
- Susan Shelley: Keys to the White House suggest that Trump will prevail in November News In 1981, historian Allan Lichtman and the late Russian scientist Vladimir Keilis-Borok developed a model for predicting U.S. presidential elections. “The 13 Keys to the White House” was based on the results of elections from Abraham Lincoln to Ronald Reagan. It has correctly predicted the outcome of every presidential election…
- Letter: Ronald Reagan actually was great, Larry Wilson and Max Boot are wrong News Larry Wilson’s column about Reagan is way off. “Not that great” really? All he did was end the threat of nuclear war and win the Cold War that had been going on for 45 years with the threat of mutual annihilation without firing a shot. “Not that great?” Really? Reagan “supply…
- Letter: Trump is the fighter America needs News Do any of the politicians’ words heed serious consideration? There is a serious problem in the majority of America that continues to accept the same old jargon spewed every election cycle. Yes, Trump speaks in hyperbole. It does seem he can’t help himself to defend himself against lies. But it…
- 49ers’ 5 keys to finally beating Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs News SANTA CLARA – Colton McKivitz’s leg once got caught on an electric, barbed-wire fence while turkey hunting with his dad. He considers it the best scar on his 6-foot-6, 301-pound body. Then there is the psychological scar he and his 49ers teammates bear from their Super Bowl LVIII loss eight…
- All eyes on Arturas Karnisovas and five other keys for the Bulls season News Arturas Karnisovas is about to venture out on the toughest challenge facing him as Bulls lead-dog executive. Firing Jim Boylen, overturning the roster for the start of the 2021-22 season … child’s play considering what’s on Karnisovas’ plate for the 2024-25 campaign. If he does this right, Karnisovas will be…
(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)