Susan Shelley’s critique of Allan Lichtman’s “13 Keys to the White House” misinterprets his framework. Lichtman, with a proven record, defined the criteria, so claiming he’s “wrong” is misguided.
For Key 3 (no serious contest for the incumbent), Shelley argues the Democratic primary was contested because Kamala Harris took over after Biden stepped down. But the party overwhelmingly rallied behind her, which aligns with Lichtman’s definition.
On Key 8 (civil unrest), Shelley points to protests and social tensions, but Lichtman defines unrest as sustained instability during the election. While unrest exists, it doesn’t meet that threshold.
Finally, Key 13 (the challenger is uncharismatic): Trump excites his base, but Lichtman’s definition requires broad appeal, which Trump lacks. Harris, however, may fit the bill.
Shelley’s deviations from Lichtman’s definitions weaken her critique. Therefore, Harris is poised to become the first woman of mixed race to shatter the ultimate glass ceiling in American politics.
Elaine Neff, Mission Hills
Letter: Trump is the fighter America needs
Letter: Ronald Reagan actually was great, Larry Wilson and Max Boot are wrong
Letter: Trump exaggerates when he speaks, but he has the right ideas to fix America’s problems
Letter: Trump supporters like his way of speaking but don’t want us to take him seriously
Letter: Kamala Harris deserves credit for at least going on Fox News
Related Posts:
- Susan Shelley: Slow counts show election system needs reform News With the election finally over, and America getting ready to celebrate its fall holiday tradition of families not speaking to each other, it’s good to remember that there is one thing that unites us all. In every region of the country, people of every age, race, color, creed, religion and…
- Susan Smith is denied parole 30 years after drowning 2 sons by rolling car into South Carolina lake News By JEFFREY COLLINS and MAKIYA SEMINERA COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A parole board decided unanimously Wednesday that Susan Smith should remain in prison 30 years after she killed her sons by rolling her car into a South Carolina lake while they were strapped in their car seats. It was the first parole…
- Gary Neville admits ‘I got it wrong’ and apologises over Rashford criticism as Amorim demands Man Utd ‘change’ Sports MANCHESTER UNITED icon Gary Neville has apologised for his criticism of Marcus Rashford and Casemiro in the wake of their trip to the USA last week. The duo spent the international break in the States after missing out on a call-up to their respective national teams. YouTube/Sky Sports Premier LeagueGary…
- Got questions about A-Basin’s new paid parking policy? We’ve got answers. News Arapahoe Basin’s new paid parking requirement is still a month out, but officials there concede there has been some criticism among ski area loyalists. “We’re getting mixed reviews,” said spokeswoman Shayna Silverman. “Anytime there is change at the resort, we’re faced with criticism. Some folks are excited to be assured…
- Letter: Trump continues to assemble his Cabinet of Clowns News As Trump continues to assemble his Cabinet of Clowns, much has been made of his nomination of Matt Gaetz to head the Justice Dept. In light of all the controversy surrounding Gaetz’ (alleged) dalliances with underage teenagers, would Trump decide to withdraw the nomination? Asked this, his answer was an…
(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)