Spanking machines and electric shock shoes — welcome to the world of America’s fraternal societies
Let’s talk about spanking.
Not the kind that went out of fashion among exasperated parents decades ago. Rather, the kind involving fully grown, consenting adults — mostly men — pillars of their various communities, wearing starched collars, suits, wingtips.
Veiled in secrecy, America’s fraternal societies have long had a taint of weirdness — at least among those on the outside. Their enigmatic rituals fostered rumors of secret cabals and plans for world domination.
The collection of some 361 curiosities — including a 1909 “lifting and spanking machine” — now on display at the Northwest Side’s Potter & Potter Auctions house will do little to snuff out the myths.
As of Friday morning, there was already a bid of $325 for the device, which originally came with a 32-caliber blank cartridge that exploded when the paddle struck the buttocks. The actual auction begins at 10 a.m. Oct. 9; that’s when the pre-auction highest (online or phone) bid becomes the auction’s opening bid. Register at potterauctions.com.
Devices like the “Lifting and Spanking” machine were commonly used in initiation rituals.
Anthony Vazquez, Sun-Times.
Most of the collection belongs to Bruce Lee Webb, a Texas folk artist and gallery owner. Webb belongs to several fraternal organizations: the Freemasons, The Independent Order of Odd Fellows and the Knights of Pythias. He began collecting fraternal order regalia and other items at flea markets in the 1980s and then later on eBay, at a time when lodges across the United States were closing.
“So much of the material has been thrown away. Early on I realized there was a sense of urgency to get out and preserve what I could,” Webb, 59, said during a recent chat with the Chicago Sun-Times.
Now, he and his wife Julie are downsizing and don’t have enough space in their converted Masonic lodge in Fort Davis in Texas, he said.
“In small towns in the past, this is where people got together to learn the news, got to know each other before the era of people meeting online,” Webb said of the early popularity of American fraternal life.
Spanking machines, sandals that delivered an electric shock and a ride on a mechanical goat were all part of the “high jinks” or the sometimes over-the-top initiation rituals, Webb said. Many of the devices came from DeMoulin Bros. and Co., a downstate company perhaps best known these days for making marching band uniforms.
Odd Fellows Costume Visor Helmets at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
1 of 34
Odd Fellows Costume Hats at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
2 of 34
A souvenir book at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
3 of 34
Knights of Pythias Initiation Stocks at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
4 of 34
Odd Fellows Carved Crooks and a Carved Knife at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
5 of 34
Masonic hats Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
6 of 34
Boxed Sets of Ceremonial Tools at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
7 of 34
Masonic Hats at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
8 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
9 of 34
Shriners Large Mid-Century Neon Sign Circa 1950 at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
10 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
11 of 34
Oriental Consistory Scottish Rite at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
12 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
13 of 34
Ark of the Covenant. (I.O.O.F.) at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
14 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
15 of 34
A lifting and spanking machine from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
16 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
17 of 34
Various items from fraternal organizations at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
18 of 34
Aron Packer, Director & Specialist, Fine & Outsider Art, shows off banner for different lodges at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
19 of 34
Aron Packer, Director & Specialist, Fine & Outsider Art, pushes a DeMoulin Bros. & Co. “Royal Bumper” Mechanical Goat at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
20 of 34
A souvenir book at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
21 of 34
Odd Fellows Ark of the Covenant with Angels at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
22 of 34
Pair of Odd Fellows Springed Sandals at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
23 of 34
Various banners from different organization at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
24 of 34
Knights of Pythias Costume at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
25 of 34
Various banners from fraternal organizations and an ELKS lodge neon sign at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
26 of 34
Ancient Mystic Order of Samaritans Parade Banner at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
27 of 34
Masonic 14th Degree Carved Hand Staff at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
28 of 34
A fraternal apron at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
29 of 34
Various odd fellow swords at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
30 of 34
Odd fellow hair painted wire mask at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
31 of 34
The Road Less Traveled a Fraternal Initiation Prop at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
32 of 34
at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
33 of 34
A dd Fellows Two Person Horse Costume at Potter & Potter Auction house at 5001 W Belmont Ave in Belmont Cragin, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2025. The auction house will present “Belonging: Secrets, Goats, and Signs – The Art of American Fraternal Societies” which will auction art, ritual objects, and photos from various organizations.
| Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times
34 of 34
Fraternal orders got their start in Europe as guilds for various tradesmen. The Freemasons, for example, can trace their roots to the stone masons in England and Scotland during the Middle Ages.
In America, fraternal organizations fostered a sense of belonging — among men who missed the camaraderie of the Civil War and World War I military life, Webb said. They also offered job-seeking men a chance to meet potential employers.
In his book “As Above, So Below: Art of the American Fraternal Society, 1850-1930,” Webb explains more of the appeal of the secret society: “Lodge rooms offered men an escape from mounting societal pressures, from the complexities of modern life, from the confining realities of daily routines, and from the company of women.”
The groups emphasized morality, charity and belief in a higher power, although organizations often stayed away from any particular religion.
Men could also indulge their creative side, Webb said, putting on, say, an elaborate theatrical production infused with Egyptian, Etruscan or perhaps Greek symbols.
It’s hard to overstate the importance of these organizations in men’s lives. High jinks aside, the initiation was supposed to be akin to a religious experience, Webb said.
Odd Fellows Grand High Priest King costume made of red velvet and silk
Anthony Vazquez, Sun-Times
“The whole process should be made one of the most crucial experiences of the candidate’s life, one that will change him to the center of his being. … As a result of it, the candidate should become a new man,” H. L. Haywood, a well-known Masonic scholar, wrote in 1923.
Traipse through almost any Illinois cemetery today , and you’ll likely find many symbols of fraternal organizations, including the all-seeing eye and a grave marker carved to look like a tree stump — symbolic of woodcraft workers.
Besides the quirky stuff — like an initiation “lung tester” that expelled soot or cornstarch when the unsuspecting user blew into it — the collection includes many pieces of skilled craftsmanship, including elaborately stitched ceremonial robes and tunics and glittering silk parade banners.
Webb argues that anyone in America should find something of interest in the collection.
“Ancient folklore and traditions are being forgotten. These lodges are a thread that connects us with the past or the culture of our not-too-distant ancestors,” he said.
But don’t expect to discover, among the hundreds of items set to go on the auction block, a clue to the Freemasons’ secret plot to rule the world.
“We’re not trying to rule the world. If Freemasons were out to take over the world, they haven’t done the best job in just keeping the order going,” Webb said.
Related Posts:
Fundraising groups step up to help reopen national park sites and welcome visitors News By COLLEEN SLEVIN DENVER (AP) — When the government shut down in 2018, a Mississippi nonprofit interceded to fund a bare-bones crew to keep one of the state’s most-visited cultural attractions operating. Now, the group is committed to doing that for Vicksburg National Military Park once again. Related Articles Federal…
Plans to contain harmful gases, improve electric grid in Illinois nixed by Trump News A plan to help energy companies, local governments and others pay for programs to reduce harmful methane and other gas emissions was canceled by President Donald Trump’s administration this week. The grants included other initiatives, including improvement to the electric grid. Nearly $600 million in previously promised government grants to…
Trump pulls plug on expanding solar program that cuts Illinois electric bills News Gerald Jones used to pay hundreds of dollars a month for gas and electric service to his Chatham home. With 23 solar panels installed on his South Side bungalow last year, he now pays as low as $75 a month. That savings is also the result of better home insulation…
RTD’s plans to borrow $539 million for diesel buses, sidelining hopes for electric News RTD directors for years have prioritized converting metro Denver’s aging fleet of 995 diesel-powered buses to cleaner, quieter battery-electric vehicles, in line with Colorado’s climate goals. But agency officials are buying new diesel buses instead — and planning to borrow $539 million for diesel bus purchases over the next five…
Brentwood man seriously injured in electric scooter crash News BRENTWOOD — An electric scooter rider was seriously injured in a crash Friday in Brentwood, police said. Related Articles Climbing star dies in fall from Yosemite’s El Capitan Two Delta Air Lines jets damaged in ‘low-speed collision’ on New York airport taxiway, injuring 1 CHP: Embattled Bay Area businessman blacked…
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.