The St. Louis Cardinals entered the offseason prepared to reshape their roster, but few moves would hit harder than trading Lars Nootbaar. As rival executives increasingly view St. Louis as the winter’s most aggressive seller, Nootbaar’s name surfacing in talks with the Los Angeles Dodgers highlights exactly how much the Cardinals may be willing to sacrifice to reset their direction.
Reporting from The Athletic indicates the Dodgers are among the teams tracking Nootbaar as St. Louis fields calls across its roster. While names like Nolan Arenado and Willson Contreras dominate speculation, Nootbaar represents a different kind of risk. He embodies development success, roster balance, and an identity the Cardinals have struggled to maintain in recent seasons.
What the Cardinals Lose on the Field
Nootbaar has established himself as one of the Cardinals’ most dependable everyday players. He plays all three outfield positions, provides above-average defense, and brings a disciplined offensive approach built on plate control and on-base ability. That skill set reflects the profile St. Louis once developed consistently—and now rarely replaces internally.
If the Cardinals trade him, they weaken an outfield that already lacks clarity. The organization has cycled through short-term fixes and positional experiments for years. Nootbaar stands out as one of the few internally developed outfielders who still project as a multi-year contributor rather than a placeholder. Removing him forces St. Louis to rely on unproven options or to spend resources replacing production they already had.
The loss would extend beyond lineup construction. Nootbaar’s approach at the plate helps stabilize an offense that often struggles with inconsistency. His defensive reliability reduces pressure on pitching staffs that have carried an increasing burden. Trading him strips away one of the roster’s most adaptable pieces.
What Trading Nootbaar Signals About the Direction
Nootbaar’s age and contract status make this decision even more revealing. He remains in his prime and under team control, which usually makes a player untouchable for clubs attempting to stay competitive. If St. Louis moves him now, the organization signals a willingness to prioritize longer-term restructuring over near-term stability.
Health concerns add nuance but do not erase value. Nootbaar is expected to miss some early time after double heel surgery, yet teams continue to show interest. That demand creates temptation. The Cardinals must decide whether maximizing trade value now outweighs keeping a proven contributor through a transitional season.
The risk lies in what follows. Nootbaar offers traits the Cardinals have struggled to replace: patience, defensive versatility, and athleticism. Removing him shifts immediate pressure onto younger players who have not yet proven they can handle everyday roles. It also narrows the margin for error in a division that continues to prioritize efficiency over star power.
If Nootbaar ends up in Los Angeles, the move will not register as a blockbuster. It will register as something more unsettling. The Cardinals would lose a player who fit both the present and the future—one who represented continuity during an era of instability. That kind of subtraction often reveals more about an organization’s direction than any headline-grabbing trade ever could.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Cardinals Could Regret Trading Outfielder Sooner Than They Think appeared first on Heavy Sports.