The Mariners and Tigers have never faced each other in the postseason. For both franchises, this ALDS represents a chance to break new ground, and for fans, decades of hopes tied to October finally collide. Seattle reached this point by virtue of winning the AL West and earning a first-round bye, while Detroit advanced through a Wild Card win over Cleveland.
The narrative stakes are high. The Mariners are chasing their first-ever trip to the World Series and haven’t been to the ALCS since 2001. Detroit, meanwhile, hasn’t been to the ALCS in 12 years and is trying to build postseason momentum after back-to-back Wild Card appearances. This matchup is bridging historical droughts as much as it is about 2025’s team strengths.
Expert Picks & Odds: Mariners Favored
CBS Sports experts generally lean toward Seattle in this series. Their logic: better regular-season record, more pitching depth, and fewer question marks in roster construction. Some pick Mariners in 4, others entertain a possible 5-game path.
That said, the odds aren’t lopsided. Seattle is favored (series line -175), but Detroit’s underdog status presents value, especially if they catch Seattle’s rotation off guard. Game 1 props also favor Seattle’s arms: likely matchups (George Kirby vs Troy Melton) tilt toward the Mariners with expectations of run suppression.
Experts caution that Detroit’s punch is limited, but their volatility may bite Seattle. The Tigers have proven they can break through when it matters, and they’ll lean on Tarik Skubal’s arm and opportunistic hitting.
Key Storylines to Watch
1. Pitching Health & Rotation Depth
Seattle’s ace, Bryan Woo, is reportedly not on the ALDS roster due to pectoral inflammation. His absence raises immediate questions: Who starts Game 1? How many innings can the Mariners push their rotation? How critical will bullpen usage become?
Kirby, Logan Gilbert, and Luis Castillo become more central. Their ability to eat innings and limit damage could tilt the series. Detroit, on the other hand, leans heavily on Skubal, their lone consistent starter. But beyond Skubal, their rotation depth is thinner.
2. Offensive Balance & Home Advantage
Seattle’s offense has flown under the radar at times, but it’s improved. The presence of Cal Raleigh, who led the league in home runs, gives Seattle a thunder bat in the middle of the order. Meanwhile, Detroit’s offense is streaky; when they’re hot, they embarrass pitching staffs, but if Seattle’s arms carry, the Tigers may struggle to string together consistent rally innings.
Home-field advantage matters: Seattle will host the first two games in T-Mobile Park, where they were dominant during the regular season (51-30 at home)–a setup that could allow them to build a cushion before shifting to Detroit.
3. Margin for Error & High-Leverage Moments
In a short 5-game series, tight margins and bullpen management are magnified. Seattle’s depth gives them more room to survive off nights or late-inning blunders. Detroit, on the other hand, must make every swing count and every bullpen handoff clean. A single off-day or bullpen meltdown can decide it all.
Also, roster construction choices–bench players, matchup arms, bullpen flexibility–might prove decisive. The team that better exploits matchups and holds the edge in situational opportunities probably wins the series.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Mariners vs. Tigers: ALDS Preview and Expert Predictions appeared first on Heavy Sports.