Major League Baseball has a new ball problem—and this time, they’re admitting it.
After years of swirling conspiracy theories and half-denials about “juiced” or “dead” balls, MLB confirmed to The Athletic that the 2025 baseball is performing differently than in past years. Specifically, equally hard-hit fly balls are now traveling an average of four feet shorter than they did in 2024. While the league claims there were no intentional changes to the ball’s manufacturing, it acknowledged an uptick in drag, the highest recorded in the Statcast era.
It’s a technical admission with wide-reaching consequences, particularly in a game where inches often decide outcomes.
The Drag is Real, Even if the Intent Isn’t
The league cites “normal variability” in handcrafted materials as a potential explanation, but data doesn’t lie: this year’s average drag coefficient is .3514, compared to a previous high of .3462 in 2016. MLB spokesman Glen Caplin insists nothing has changed in how the balls are stored or stitched, but the league has already briefed the Players Association. Commissioner Rob Manfred reportedly acknowledged the issue directly in private meetings with players.
The root cause remains unclear. It may be seam height, raw materials, or simple batch variation. But whatever the reason, it’s impacting the product on the field.
Four Feet Short: A Subtle Shift with Big Impacts
While four feet might seem minor, in baseball, that’s the difference between a game-tying home run and a flyout caught at the warning track.
Just ask A’s slugger Brent Rooker: “I’ve definitely hit some balls that I thought were gonna have a chance, and they’ve been caught against the wall,” he told The Athletic. His expected slugging percentage is 100 points higher than his actual mark, and the discrepancy is raising eyebrows around the league.
Home runs per fly ball have dropped to an eight-year low across 28 MLB parks despite hitters generating slightly harder contact overall. This suggests the suppressed ball flight isn’t just a statistical anomaly—it’s a hidden hand-shaping outcome.
Why This Matters for Hitters and Pitchers Alike
For power hitters, especially those on the fringe of the roster or arbitration-eligible, this could be career-altering. Fewer home runs mean fewer RBIs, lower OPS, and potentially lower salary projections. For aging stars trying to prove they’ve still got pop, the ball isn’t doing them any favors.
Meanwhile, pitchers—especially those with fly-ball tendencies—might be benefiting more than we realize. With flyouts traveling shorter, ERAs could improve without any actual boost in pitch effectiveness. That adds complexity to trade deadline decisions, free agent valuations, and even Cy Young races.
This situation isn’t just a data nerd problem. It’s a real on-field issue.
MLB’s Pattern of Ball Mysteries Continues
This isn’t the first time MLB has faced scrutiny over its baseballs. From the home run surge in 2019 to the launch-deadening shift in 2021, inconsistencies have long plagued the league’s most fundamental piece of equipment. After years of silence, MLB buying a stake in Rawlings (the ball manufacturer) and mandating humidors in every park only fueled more suspicion.
Now, the league is trying to get ahead of the narrative, but without clear transparency, fans and players are still left guessing.
What’s Next? Transparency or More Confusion
MLB says gameplay is “largely unaffected.” They are pointing to similar league-wide stats in runs per game and home run rates compared to last year. But numbers can hide trends. A four-foot dip in flight might not shift league averages dramatically, but it shifts individual outcomes—and individual careers.
The question now is whether MLB will follow up with actionable findings. If this becomes yet another mystery that disappears into the humidified mist of league-controlled messaging.
Until then, hitters will keep watching long fly balls die in the air—and wondering if it’s the ball or just their luck.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post MLB Confirms ‘Big’ Issue with Baseballs: Report appeared first on Heavy Sports.