The Philadelphia Phillies are playoff-bound in name only. With a solid record and a star-studded rotation, they’re expected to be buyers at the 2025 trade deadline. But digging deeper into the numbers, there’s a case to be made that buying now could backfire.
While names like Zack Wheeler, Trea Turner, and Bryce Harper give the appearance of a contender, the offense is wildly inconsistent, and the team is leaning too heavily on aging stars and unproven depth.
Offensive Holes Run Deeper Than They Look
It’s not just about scoring runs—it’s about how the Phillies score them. The team’s offense leans almost entirely on Kyle Schwarber, who leads the club with 27 home runs and a .922 OPS. Turner has been reliable with a .301 average, and Harper (when healthy) continues to get on base at a .367 clip, but beyond that? The cracks are showing.
Nick Castellanos (.275/.318/.445) and Alec Bohm (.283/.324/.404) have been fine, but not difference-makers. Meanwhile, Bryson Stott (.236 average, .633 OPS) and Johan Rojas (.226 average, .574 OPS) have been near automatic outs.
The Phillies are carrying several low-impact bats, and they’re stuck trying to force production from guys like Max Kepler (.209/.303/.380), who’s struggled since arriving in Philly. Their overall OBP sits near league average, and when Schwarber slumps, the entire lineup disappears.
Rotation Is Elite, But Depth Is Shaky
The Phillies’ top three—Zack Wheeler (2.27 ERA), Cristopher Sánchez (2.68), and Ranger Suárez (1.99)—are elite. But Jesús Luzardo (4.44 ERA), Mick Abel (5.04), and Aaron Nola (6.16) have been wildly inconsistent.
Nola’s decline has been particularly alarming, with opponents batting .294 against him and 11 home runs allowed in under 50 innings. With Luzardo struggling and Abel untested in big moments, Philly may need to trade for another starter to stabilize the back end of the rotation.
Buying Now Means Selling Future Depth
The Phillies don’t have the deepest farm system, but to get impact help—particularly in the outfield or bullpen—they may have to shop Mick Abel, Griff McGarry, or even Aidan Miller.
That’s a steep price for a team that isn’t leading its division and has fundamental flaws. Especially when the path to October likely runs through the Wild Card, if the Mets keep winning, burning prospect capital for a short-term push could do more harm than good.
NL Contenders Will Make Things Harder
Even if the Phillies add at the deadline, there’s no clear road to the World Series. The Dodgers are loaded, the Mets are battle-tested, and the Brewers are emerging as a legitimate threat. Philadelphia will need more than a deadline rental to keep up—and that kind of upgrade doesn’t come cheap.
Philadelphia Risks Repeating 2023 Mistakes
Last season, the Phillies made a push at the deadline but came up short. They risk doing the same again—but with even more at stake. Harper and Turner are still elite, but the window doesn’t stay open forever. Making a splashy move just to “go for it” now might set the team back two or three years.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Phillies Expected to Buy at Deadline—But the Offense Isn’t Good Enough appeared first on Heavy Sports.