Jimmy Fallon didn’t switch teams on Thursday night. He simply showed up as who he’s always been: a New Yorker rooting for the Yankees. That didn’t stop a wave of outrage from corners of Red Sox Twitter that still view him through the 2005 rom-com “Fever Pitch,” where he played a diehard Boston fan running onto the field after the 2004 World Series. When the ESPN broadcast cut to Fallon jumping and fist-pumping during the Yankees’ four-run inning, the discourse lit up like a rivalry bonfire.
The loudest condemnation came from Red Sox-leaning outlets and personalities. OutKick framed the moment as a “disgusting” betrayal, zeroing in on the memory of Fallon and co-star Drew Barrymore celebrating on the field two decades ago. It’s raw Boston catharsis: if “Fever Pitch” helped canonize 2004 on screen, seeing that same face cheer a Bronx October win stings. But the premise is off—that was acting, this is real life.
The Movie Made Him A Sox Fan On Screen
Getty
Context matters. “Fever Pitch” famously rewrote its ending on the fly to capture the curse-breaking chaos of 2004, with Fallon and Barrymore sprinting onto the field in character for the final shot. That cinematic moment tied his image to Boston forever, even as the real Fallon kept sitting near the Yankees’ dugout in the years that followed.
There’s ample evidence—and years of it—that Fallon is a Yankees guy. He threw the first pitch at Yankee Stadium in 2021 with Mariano Rivera coaching him on the mound. He’s hosted Derek Jeter repeatedly on The Tonight Show. He has told interviewers that he grew up in New York, started attending Mets games, and eventually drifted to the Yankees as his career progressed through SNL and beyond. None of this is new; it just resurfaces every time the rivalry spikes.
Social Media Outrage Is Loud—And Selectively Forgetful
Clips of Fallon celebrating in the Bronx flew around timelines, packaged with lines about “switching sides” and “selling out.” NESN highlighted the broadcast shot and noted how odd it might look to Boston fans who still associate him with “Fever Pitch.” Sports blogs aggregated the backlash. Even comedy sites got in on the pile-on, turning the moment into a referendum on celebrity fandom etiquette. The through line: folks seeing what they want in a 10-second video, not the two decades of public evidence that Fallon’s Yankee loyalties were never a secret.
If anything, this flare-up says more about the state of the rivalry than about Fallon. Yankees–Red Sox remains elastic enough that a cutaway of a late-night host can hijack the conversation after a deciding game. The Yankees just advanced; Boston went home; and a celebrity reaction shot still dominates a news cycle because it taps into a deeper wound from 2004 that never fully healed. That’s the power—and the pettiness—of pinstripes vs. Boston in October.
For Yankees fans, the takeaway is simple: a famous New Yorker cheered a Yankees rally at Yankee Stadium. For Red Sox fans, it’s a reminder that the movie magic of 2004 blurred the line between character and actor in a way that was always going to come back to haunt them when the teams met again in a big spot. It’s a good lesson in separating the bit from the brand—and remembering that, in this rivalry, even a B-roll reaction can become bulletin-board material.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Red Sox Fans Rip Jimmy Fallon for Cheering Yankees appeared first on Heavy Sports.