So, here we are.
At the intersection between the small difference between experiment and theory. The Josh Giddey crossroads. Where drama surrounding his existence in a Bulls uniform is beginning to metastasize.
Experiments, if given the chance, should, by nature, be given the chance to be and end wrong. That doesn’t mean they are wrong; it just means a different or other route needs to be taken to get to the conclusion sought. To make the experiment not become an enigma.
Giddey running the point for the Bulls is an experiment. Year 3 is so far proving to be his Stage 5, the ‘‘Analyze Data and Draw Conclusion’’ part. The precursor to (the Bulls) facing a conclusion. Even as his 18-point, 14-rebound, nine-assist, four-turnover ‘‘bounce-back from the fourth quarter benching’’ game Wednesday showed the type of player Giddey needs to be for the Bulls to discover whom they can become, the inconsistency and unknowing of when another game like that will happen is equivalent of Giddey not saving himself from himself.
A CHGO Sports podcast clamped down on Giddey like Payton Pritchard in the Boston game and targeted him like most defenses seem to be doing whenever he has the rock: ‘‘The effort, the compete level was not there in a way it needed to be.’’ ‘‘It’s never good when my starting point guard in the fourth quarter of a game is unplayable.’’ ‘‘Is this guy good enough to lead your team when you’re playing at the highest level? From what I’ve seen this year . . . I don’t see it.’’ ‘‘I would like a real point guard on my team, please.’’
Between Matt Peck, Will Gottlieb and Big Dave Watson, the theory of Giddey was on full blast. ESPN apparently (according to Bulls Central) didn’t help by saying Giddey was (possibly) not in executive vice president Bryson Graham’s plan and instigating the term ‘‘bridge player’’ into his situation.
Of the fourth quarter benching, Giddey’s ‘‘ . . . that’s a point guard’s job. If I can’t do that, I probably shouldn’t be a point guard’’ comments he made about himself Monday that got points for his 100% realness somehow missed the credit that should have come with it for being the truth. As he may hold the answer to the conclusion of his own experiment.
The theory is that it’s the turnovers. It’s not just the turnovers; it’s more than that. Through the games so far that have made up this Bulls season, Giddey has fallen below his career ‘‘C-level’’ averages in other areas: field-goal and three-point percentages down, free-throw percentage way down, win shares down to below the fault line (-0.1), points and rebounds down, PER down.
All of which, when you compare his turnover average this season with his career average (3.3 versus 2.9), doesn’t come off as drastic as the conversation seems to be making it out to be.
Still, here we are.
The why of this trial (and error) run is a different piece of rhetoric. One that falls under the same ominous cloud as the Noa Essengue Experiment, the Patrick Williams Experiment, last season’s draft-deadline experiment — which included the horrific four-game, two-month Jaden Ivey Experiment and the miserably failed Ayo Dosunmu Experiment the Bulls decided to end before completion — if they fail to play this smart.
Like scientists instead of coaches and executives.
What cannot be overlooked, overstated enough or misunderstood in any way in this is the role playing alongside Coby White and Dosunmu had on Giddey’s play at the point during their tenures here. While Giddey ran the point during the last two seasons, the full responsibility of doing it was never all on him. Now it is. Which is a whole other ballgame.
Uncomfortable is what he is, theoretically. What he has been inside this experiment. The Bulls are forcing him to be something he’s not. Like the Bears did Devin Hester at wide receiver. It’s not that Giddey can’t play point, he just hasn’t found the way to do it without losing his entire style of play and the benefits that come with that. He also has not yet found anyone to lead him the right way into that transition. Which is coming at both the team’s and his expense.
Maybe he should call Ty Jerome and ask what’s the secret. A visit to the NBA psychological alchemist Iren Rainey, maybe?
An improbable half-court, game-ending, buzzer-beater in 2025 at the UC to beat the LeBron/Luka-led Lakers that will go down as his career promise. A shot by Giddey that, at the time, was believed (or desperately taken) to be the beginning of the Bulls’ return to (any) meaningful basketball-related conversation.
What was lost in his 25-point, 14-rebound, 11-assist performance that night against the Lakers were the seven turnovers he accumulated running the offense. From there, it has been — or seems to have been — a slow, inconsistent decline for Giddey since.
The jagged big pill that now must be swallowed: The Josh Giddey Experiment is an experiment gone wrong. He’s not wrong (as a player), the Bulls aren’t wrong (as a team for experimenting), he’s just the wrong player to be the orchestrator of this symphony. They both know they need to realign their whole line of thinking.
Yet, here we are.