‘These chairs belong to the hostages. We haven’t forgotten you.’

Chairs outside Am Shalom synagogue in Glencoe, with photos of hostages taken from Israel on Oct. 7 by Hamas.

Provided

In the days following the horrific attack on Israel in the early hours of Oct. 7, when 1,200 people were brutally murdered by Hamas and more than 230 individuals were taken hostage from their homes and from the Nova Music Festival, we felt helpless. Posters were hung with the names and faces of those who were stolen, only to be torn down. A ground invasion of Gaza was getting underway and protests began. There was so much noise, which made the silence about the hostages deafening.

A few weeks after Oct. 7, I walked into our weekly staff meeting with an idea inspired by the long Shabbat table set just outside of the Tel Aviv Art Museum, a stark reminder that our own tables were not complete. That brisk afternoon, our staff placed 248 chairs at the corner of Vernon and Greenwood, outside Am Shalom synagogue, to keep the hostages front and center. We set the chairs up in rows and affixed a hostage poster to each one. In the process, we created a temporary outdoor sanctuary nearly the same size as the one inside the synagogue.

Opinion bug

Opinion

The white chairs have become our community. A family drove by the very first day and offered to put a stuffed animal on each chair, like the stuffed animals that filled the fountain area on Dizengoff Square in Tel Aviv in the early days of the war. People from the community gathered. It became a sacred spot.

For a few days last November, with relief and joy, we tied blue and white ribbons around almost 100 chairs and moved them to the front, representing the released hostages. Too many others, those confirmed dead or murdered while in captivity, were brought to the flagpole. The remaining 133 chairs continue on as a community, filled with our prayers and our hopes.

‘They are not forgotten’

Fall turned to winter and now spring and the chairs are still there, day in and day out. Grass grows wildly underneath the legs. The bitter cold and the rain have warped the wood and made the cushions soggy. Still, we continue to witness some truly amazing moments. Nearly every day, neighborhood children and families stop by to pick up the stuffed animals that fell off the chairs overnight. They watch over the area, making sure it remains clean. Strangers stop by to take pictures and to walk among the chairs to read the names. I’ve met Israelis who stood there in tears, taking photos to text back to their family members. Local pastors come to offer prayers. Government officials take pictures.

Last week, I met a new mom who was walking through to pick out a Hebrew name for her new baby, wanting to name her after one of the hostages. Early in the morning after the video of hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin was released, I found a Chicago Bulls hat on Hersh’s chair that simply said ‘SURVIVE WE LOVE YOU.’

On all three of our congregational missions to Israel since Oct. 7, we have been able to show individual hostage families, who think that the world has forgotten about their loved ones, that we in Chicago are still praying, and hoping and working for their release. They are not forgotten. These are not just chairs with pictures and posters. They are Shani’s cousin Yagev Buchshtav; Itzik’s two sons, Aitan and Iair Horn; Liora’s daughter Noa Argamani; Aviva Siegel, who was a hostage herself, and her husband Keith Siegel; and so many more real people with real stories.

They are not political pawns. They are human beings who must be reunited with their families.

We know that we can never use these chairs again. They don’t belong to us anymore. They belong to the community. These chairs, and this area where they sit, belong to the hostages. Through the chaos of the last 209 days it can be easy to forget that their lives hang in the balance and their families are living in a perpetual state of anguish.

Time is running out for all of them. Our 248 chairs will stay up as long as they have to. It is our way to say to the world: We haven’t forgotten you. We never will.

Rabbi Steven Stark Lowenstein is the Senior Rabbi of Am Shalom Congregation in Glencoe.

The Sun-Times welcomes letters to the editor and op-eds. See our guidelines.

The views and opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Chicago Sun-Times or any of its affiliates.

More Israel-Hamas War coverage
Reality on the ground is different from what policymakers understand in war rooms, far from the constant sound of bombs and drones, a Chicago-area doctor who has volunteered in Gaza writes. Thaer Ahmad, a Palestinian American, walked out of a meeting with President Joe Biden about a month ago and is calling for a cease-fire in Gaza.
After Oct. 7, chairs with the photos of hostages seized in Israel by Hamas were placed outside Am Shalom synagogue in Glencoe, waiting for the hostages’ release. “Our 248 chairs will stay up as long as they have to,” Am Shalom’s senior rabbi writes.
The group the People’s Art Institute accused law enforcement of yanking people’s hair, strangling them, and hitting people with batons and metal fences at the Saturday protest.
Around daybreak Tuesday, campus officers surrounded the university’s main quadrangle and kept students from entering, according to reports from the scene.
Según los informes, en el campus de Lincoln Park de DePaul los contra manifestantes intentaron enfrentarse a los manifestantes, pero los pro palestinos utilizaron tácticas de desescalada para mantener la paz. En todo el país se ha detenido a más de 2,500 manifestantes desde el 18 de abril.
The University of Chicago Faculty for Justice in Palestine on Monday reaffirmed support for the “peaceful, welcoming and educational space” students had created and called on school leadership to return to “good-faith” negotiations.
An official familiar with Israeli thinking says Israeli officials are examining the cease-fire proposal approved by Hamas. But the official warns that the plan “is not the framework Israel proposed.”
Counterprotesters at DePaul’s Lincoln Park campus reportedly tried to clash with pro-Palestinian protesters. Nationwide, more than 2,500 protesters have been arrested since April 18.
Police said the museum asked them to clear the encampment on Saturday, hours after organizers set up tents in the Art Institute’s North Garden which they said were intended to pressure the school regarding the “occupation of Palestine.”
On a mostly peaceful day, tensions briefly bubbled over when counter-protesters confronted the demonstrators at the university’s Edward Levi Hall. An altercation prompted campus police to respond.
Las protestas contra la guerra han invadido los campus universitarios en las últimas semanas. Los estudiantes apoyan a los palestinos en los ataques de Israel contra Gaza, denuncian lo que llaman censura por parte de sus universidades y piden a las instituciones que dejen de invertir en fabricantes de armas y empresas que apoyan a Israel.
Classes disrupted, fellow students threatened, clashes with police, and the yo-yo story has to wait.
Tensions were higher Tuesday when hundreds of New York police officers raided Columbia University and City College of New York while a group of counterprotesters attacked a student encampment at UCLA.
The backlash comes days after the university made an agreement with encampment organizers to take steps toward divesting from Israel.
“I remember coming out of my apartment one day and spotting Chicago cops dragging young protesters out of one section of Lincoln Park and shoving them into trucks, while nearby poet Allen Ginsberg was chanting in a circle of peaceful protesters not far away from the radical Abby Hoffman,” remembers Dan Webb, who later became a U.S. attorney.
El campus se une a las protestas en todo el país para pedir a las universidades que dejen de invertir en empresas que apoyan a Israel.
Anti-war protests have swept college campuses in recent weeks as students support Palestinians in Israel’s attacks on Gaza, decry what they call censorship from their universities and call on institutions to divest from weapons manufacturers and companies supporting Israel.
They are willing to risk the completion of degrees or acquiring police records as allies of suffering civilians in Gaza, a reader from Hyde Park says.
The campus joins protests across the country calling on universities to divest from companies supporting Israel.
The two-part, four-hour film on WTTW comes just in time for the 750th anniversary of a key event in Dante’s life.
Déjà vu is a heck of a thing. Whether it’s 1970 or 2024, war weighs heavily on campuses — and on athletes.
Hundreds of University of Chicago students set up an encampment in the Main Quadrangle on Monday, joining groups on over 100 university campuses nationwide in support of Palestinians.
“Bad actors are using the cover of free speech in this moment of tension to normalize dangerous ideas that cause real harm to Jewish students and communities,” the museum said. But a member of Chicago’s Jewish Voice for Peace said the protesters are saying what Jewish institutions are “afraid to say.”
As the death toll mounts in the war in Gaza and the humanitarian crisis worsens, protesters at universities all over the U.S. are demanding that schools cut financial ties to Israel and divest from companies they say are enabling the conflict.
Hundreds of protesters from the University of Chicago, the School of the Art Institute of Chicago, Columbia College Chicago and Roosevelt University rallied in support of people living in Gaza.
Students linked arms and formed a line against police after Northwestern leaders said the tent encampment violated university policy. By 9 p.m. protest leaders were told by university officials that arrests could begin later in the evening.
The joint statement is the latest attempt at public pressure to advance negotiations over a potential cease-fire with Israel.
The video is the first proof of life of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, who was captured Oct. 7 in southern Israel. His parents have Chicago ties. Last week, his mother was named one of Time magazine’s most influential people of 2024.
A window of the Andersonville feminist bookstore displaying a Palestine flag and a sign calling for a cease-fire in the Israel-Hamas war was shattered early Wednesday. Police are investigating.
The Democratic president Wednesday reached the end of a long, painful battle with Republicans to secure urgently needed replenishment of aid for Ukraine.
(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *