There I was at the interval of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest at the Old Vic Theatre, having a thought I never expected to have in a theatre: ‘Should I ask for a lid for my wine, or just accept that I’ll probably taste Aaron Pierre’s sweat?’
Meanwhile, the woman in front of me calmly cleaned her perspiration-splattered glasses as if this were precisely what she expected from her ticketed experience.
It feels important to stress that this viscerality is neither accidental nor a bad thing.
Clint Dyer stages One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in the round, a two-tiered structure that places the audience uncomfortably close to the action and, crucially, within splash range of its leading man, who never quite breaks the fourth wall but does lightly mist it.
I don’t mean to sound ungrateful, as I’m well aware there are people who would pay a premium to be covered in Aaron Pierre’s sweat. Here, it’s included in the ticket price, and that really is a deal.
Jokes aside, Aaron Pierre’s Randle McMurphy is far more than just a soaked pair of scrubs; he treats the shadow of Jack Nicholson like a dare, not a burden, and delivers a version of the antihero that feels entirely his own.
The first impression is jarring. McMurphy arrives like a tornado of energy, and whatever relaxed charm you might expect from a man who routinely appears on lists of the most beautiful men alive never materialises.
Pierre’s McMurphy barrels in twitching, blinking, jaw grinding, his body held at a peculiar backward tilt as though he’s perpetually bracing to headbutt or kiss anyone who gets in range.
His American accent leans heavily into a Southern drawl that occasionally tips towards caricature, and there are moments where it threatens to pull focus.
For a short stretch, I can feel the audience weighing it all up, wondering if the final effect is something brilliant or embarrassingly overwrought.
Then it settles. Or rather, you settle into it. The performance gathers its own logic, its own momentum, and suddenly the excess feels deliberate.
There’s an infectious quality to what Pierre is doing, a sense of mischief and agitation that spreads outward, much like McMurphy’s influence on the ward.
It helps that he’s genuinely funny, pushing just far enough to make people laugh while keeping an edge of unease.
Casting one of the most strikingly beautiful men working today as a grubby, manipulative outcast could have gone very wrong, but Pierre leans into the contradiction. The result is something unsettling, a man who is magnetic and repellent in the same breath, exactly what McMurphy needs to be.
You can viscerally feel how much of himself he is pouring into the role. By the interval, that effort is dripping off him and, occasionally, onto you.
Around him, there is strong support. Giles Terera brings a lovely precision to Dale Harding, all careful diction and suppressed panic, often acting as the eye of the storm when everything else threatens to spin off its axis.
The ensemble leans into the production’s dark humour, with the build-up to the inmates’ final party landing in genuine waves of laughter.
Dyer’s broader vision is more uneven, though not entirely unsuccessful. This is a Cuckoo’s Nest relocated to New Orleans, framed through Black experience and power structures, with a predominantly Black patient group overseen by a white authority.
The imagery is clear from the outset, with Mardi Gras Indian chants and later musical cues that gesture towards a shared cultural and historical weight. You understand what’s being said, and the ward becomes a microcosm for systems of control, for the quiet confidence of those who believe themselves entitled to rule.
At its best, this reframing adds urgency and context that sharpens the material, which is — particularly in its treatment of women — dated.
At other moments, it sits awkwardly on top of the original text, especially when it reaches for connections that don’t quite hold.
The handling of Chief Bromden (played by Arthur Boan, who is of Métis heritage from Saskatchewan, Canada, and grew up in the Moose Cree First Nation Community) is the most strained, with attempts to draw parallels between Black and Native American experiences that feel underdeveloped and, in places, downright clumsy.
The appearance of his spectral father, styled in a fringed vest that looks like a Halloween costume and holding a cow skull, edges towards cringeworthy, pulling you out of the world rather than deepening it.
Still, the production lands its emotional blows where it counts. There are moments of real beauty in the staging, flashes where everything aligns and the play’s themes cut through with clarity.
And threading through it all is Pierre, vibrating at a frequency that seems just shy of sustainable, dragging the audience along with him whether they like it or not.
Got a story?
If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.