James Bond hopeful lost role after making ‘terrible joke’ during casting

Welsh actor Matthew Rhys arrives for the 78th Primetime Emmy Awards at the Peacock Theatre at LA Live in Los Angeles on September 14, 2026. (Photo by Frederic J. Brown / AFP via Getty Images)
Matthew Rhys has revealed how a poorly judged joke derailed his James Bond audition (Picture: Frederic J. Brown / AFP via Getty Images)

Matthew Rhys has revealed how an ill-advised attempt at comedy may have cost him the chance to become James Bond, admitting he spectacularly misjudged the room during his audition.

The Welsh actor, 52, was among those being considered to succeed Pierce Brosnan as 007 in the early Noughties, before Daniel Craig was ultimately handed the keys to the Aston Martin.

And while Rhys has since proved himself more than capable of playing a convincing international spy, his meeting with the custodians of Britain’s most famous secret agent could hardly have gone worse.

Appearing on Conan O’Brien’s podcast, the actor recalled being summoned to the offices of the Broccoli family overlooking London’s Green Park to discuss the prospect of playing Bond.

Asked how the meeting went, Rhys dryly responded: ‘Well I’m not playing Bond, nor have I been.’

Things initially appeared to be going reasonably well, with the conversation touching on whether Rhys had read Ian Fleming’s Casino Royale, the novel that introduced the world to 007.

Rhys jokingly suggested his incarnation of Bond should have a limp and an eye patch (Picture: ConanO’Brien)

It was when the casting panel invited him to share his creative vision for the character, however, that proceedings went spectacularly awry.

Recalling being asked what he would do differently with Bond, Rhys said: ‘As a terrible joke, I said, “Limp”.’

Rather than attempting to salvage the situation, the actor doubled down, suggesting that his incarnation of the suave secret agent might also sport an eye patch.

Unfortunately, nobody on the other side of the table appeared particularly receptive to his radical reinvention of the character.

‘It went very quiet and then I just fell apart,’ he remembered.

Craig, now 58, would instead usher in a grittier era for the franchise with 2006’s Casino Royale, going on to play Bond in five films before bowing out with No Time To Die in 2021.

SANTA MONICA, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 04: Matthew Rhys attends the 31st Annual Critics Choice Awards at Barker Hangar on January 04, 2026 in Santa Monica, California. (Photo by Monica Schipper/Getty Images)
Rhys went on to demonstrate his espionage credentials in acclaimed spy drama The Americans (Picture: Monica Schipper/Getty Images)

Despite his disastrous encounter with the Bond producers, Rhys would eventually get his opportunity to demonstrate his espionage credentials in a considerably different capacity.

He spent six seasons playing undercover Soviet intelligence officer Philip Jennings in the critically acclaimed series The Americans, opposite his now real-life partner Keri Russell.

The performance earned him an Emmy in 2018, and his career has scarcely suffered for his failure to impress the Broccolis.

In fact, Rhys enjoyed a historic evening at this year’s Emmy Awards, walking away with two leading actor trophies for two entirely different television programmes.

He was recognised for his performance as the beleaguered mayor of a potentially cursed New England island in Apple TV’s horror-comedy Widow’s Bay, as well as his decidedly more sinister turn in Netflix thriller The Beast in Me.

British actor Matthew Rhys attends the Apple TV 2026 Emmy nominees party at NYA Studios West in Hollywood, California on September 14, 2026. (Photo by Unique Nicole / AFP via Getty Images)
Rhys made history at this year’s Emmy Awards with two leading actor wins (Picture: Unique Nicole / AFP via Getty Images)

The latter saw him star opposite Claire Danes as a wealthy property developer whose first wife’s disappearance becomes an object of fascination for his novelist neighbour.

His wins made him the first male performer to have secured leading actor Emmys across the drama, comedy and limited series categories.

Meanwhile, the notoriously secretive Bond casting process has been back in the spotlight following the announcement that Robert Pattinson will become the next actor to assume the iconic role.

The Twilight and The Batman star, 40, will lead the franchise into a new era under Dune director Denis Villeneuve, following Amazon MGM Studios’ acquisition of creative control from longstanding producers Barbara Broccoli and Michael G Wilson.

Quite how Pattinson distinguished himself from the competition during his own audition remains a mystery, although it’s probably safe to assume he stopped short of suggesting an eye patch.

(Visited 2 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *