USC quarterback Jayden Maiava has been a puzzling watch this season.
When he’s at his best, Maiava is decisive. He goes through his progressions unflinchingly as the offensive line holds off pressure, allowing him to flick a forceful short- or medium-length pass.
But when the pendulum swings the opposite direction, Maiava is a mixed bag of disaster. He makes poor decisions when suffocated by the pocket, or throws off his back foot to a target that’s out of place or covered by a defender.
Saturday’s loss at Indiana, which dropped No. 18 USC to 7-3 on the season and 4-3 in the Big Ten, appeared to have shaken him and resulted in his lowest overall grade of the season from Pro Football Focus – a 48.9. He looked like a good quarterback rather than a great one.
“I don’t view this as a major stock-up or stock-down performance, but it was a revealing sample that encapsulated his inconsistency as a prospect,” NFL draft and college football analyst Todd McShay wrote in a Substack post. “We saw encouraging command and processing, but also costly decision-making.”
Roughly four months remain until the NFL draft begins April 29, and there are still two Big Ten games and a to-be-decided bowl game in between now and then.
The 6-foot-4, 230-pound senior, who’s projected to be a Day 2 draft pick after his second season as the Trojans’ full-time starter, is taking the good with the bad as he finishes out his college career.
The physical
Maiava’s comfort zone this season is in the short-to-medium passing range, especially down the middle of the field. He’s averaging 22.2 yards per pass, according to Hudl IQ analytics, and getting the ball most often to freshman wide receiver Trent Mosley.
The two make a great pair. Mosley creates separation to stay ready for a short pass from Maiava, and his 8.6 average yards after catch prove he can elude defensive players.
Maiava is leading the Big Ten with 283.5 yards per game while completing 66.3% of his passes. He’s tied for the most interceptions in the conference with eight.
The incomplete passes and interceptions are largely confined to the outer edges of the field, unlike last season’s 10 interceptions that happened at a range of distances and locations.

Terrell Anderson may have been the man to make those catches, if he were healthy. The 6-foot-2, 200-pound junior was one of USC’s best transfer portal pickups, but the potential was thwarted when he underwent a season-ending knee injury just three games into the season.
Anderson was one of the most explosive pass-catchers in the ACC last season while playing for North Carolina State, ranking 24th in receptions over 10 yards (23), 11th in catches over 20 yards (11) and sixth in receptions over 30 yards (6). He even had a 75-yard touchdown catch off a screen pass against Duke.
Without Anderson, Maiava is working with freshman targets like Mosley, Kayden Dixon-Wyatt and tight end Mark Bowman. They among the four leading Trojans in receiving yards.
“At times, he has the ability sometimes to make it look easier than it is with this young a group,” USC head coach Lincoln Riley said, “and how he’s led those guys into some of these moments against some of these teams that we’ve played. I’ve definitely been proud of him.”
The mental
Maiava’s self-assessment on the Tuesday after the Indiana loss was blunt:
“Just generally,” he told reporters. “I didn’t play great, played (crappy). I let my teammates down.”
It’s similar to what he said immediately after the game: that he needed to be better at the quarterback position. And after the loss in Wisconsin on Oct. 24, he said he needed to “deliver better for his teammates.”
He’s typically quiet in press conferences, win or lose. The difference is that after a loss, he’s exceptionally hard on himself and offers little explanation for what happened in the game aside from his perpetual opinion that he needs to improve.
USC’s 311 passing yards against Indiana were the most that any team had put up against the Hoosiers all season and still, with three interceptions to his name, Maiava was his usual own harshest critic.
He blames his competitive spirit, and Riley knows it’s something he’s been working on.
“It does (hold him back),” Riley said. “Everybody has their weakness, right? And they’ve got to figure out, how do I flip this and make that a strength? That’s something that Jayden’s had to work for.
“There’s a big part of me that would rather have it like that because he is so team-oriented. No matter how much success he’s had or how many touchdowns he’s thrown or how much we won a game by, he always wants to look at what he did wrong and how he could be better. And I think that’s part of the reason he’s grown up and become the player he has.”
Maiava’s willingness to learn and physical traits suggest that he could be a developmental prospect for an NFL team, which isn’t unlike the path that he followed in college.
He was named the Mountain West Freshman of the Year after throwing for 3,085 yards, 17 touchdowns and 10 interceptions at UNLV, then transferred to USC. He took over as starting quarterback in the final four games of his sophomore season and improved even more as a junior.
The final games of Maiava’s senior season will define his legacy at USC. His journey isn’t complete, and he remains ready to improve.